Dear Minister in the Presidency,

Please explain the apparent discrepency between these two reports with reference to the IPID Amendment Bill.

1) From News 24, 04 September 2019... Quoting yourself...

Greater independence for IPID closer as amendment bill approved
2018-09-04 22:20
Tammy Petersen
(iStock)
(iStock)

'The Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) Amendment Bill, which aims to allow for greater independence of the police watchdog head, was on Tuesday approved in the National Assembly.

It intends to be aligned to the 2016 Constitutional Court ruling that gave the National Assembly 24 months to rectify a defect in the IPID Act, a law that essentially gives the minister of police powers to suspend, take any disciplinary steps pursuant to suspension, or remove from office the IPID executive director.

The bill will now be sent to the National Council of Provinces for concurrence.

ANC chief whip Jackson Mthembu said the amendments to the act intend to restrict political influence in the removal and suspension of the police oversight body's executive directors.

"Furthermore, the amendments give IPID more independence from the police minister. When the bill is passed into law, it will require Parliament to have an oversight role in which a two-thirds majority vote will be needed in the National Assembly to suspend, discipline or remove the executive director of IPID," he said in a statement.

"We are pleased that we were able to amend the legislation within the 24-month deadline set by the court." '

VESUS:

2) Reality: (from IOL 29 September 2019 - PLUS one year after "your" statements...

"New law strips Police Minister's powers to fire Ipid head
POLITICS / 29 SEPTEMBER 2019, 4:53PM / SIYABONGA MKHWANAZI



Cape Town - The security and justice committee in the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) will soon finalise a law that will strip Minister of Police Bheki Cele of his powers to suspend or fire the head of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid).
The new law would force the minister to do this in consultation with Parliament.

The Ipid Bill is before the NCOP after it was approved by the National Assembly before the May elections. (early September 2018, actually!)

Chairperson of the select committee on security and justice in the NCOP Shahidabibi Shaik said yesterday they would reconvene next week to finalise the bill.

She said the National Assembly had already conducted public hearings on the bill.

“We should finish because during the previous term they had already run a public consultation process. The committee needs to consider those comments. We will consider those submissions we received on the Ipid Bill,” said Shaik.

“In terms of the decision of the Constitutional Court we still have to implement it. We still have a responsibility to amend the Ipid Act,” she said.

The case comes from the application by tformer Ipid head Robert McBride when when he was challenging the decision of former minister of police Nathi Nhleko to unilaterally suspend him three years ago.

In its decision in 2016 the Constitutional Court ruled in favour of McBride and said the minister of police must do this in consultation with Parliament.

The court gave Parliament until September last year to finish its process of amending the law.

However, the national legislature has missed the deadline.

This is not the only committee of Parliament to have missed the deadline of the Constitutional Court to fix a law.

The portfolio committee on rural development and land reform missed another deadline to amend the Restitution of Land Rights Act, which was passed in 2014.

In its judgment in 2016 the Constitutional Court gave Parliament two years to conclude the process of amending the Restitution of Land Rights Act. However, the national legislature missed the deadline last year July.

The act had allowed for the reopening of new land claims.

But the select committee on security and justice will reconvene next week to look at the amendments to the Ipid Bill.

The NCOP had to revive the bill after the new term of Parliament began after the elections."

I look forward to your honest reply.

Faithfully - John Wilkinson ("Eyes & Ears"... Batho Pele!)